Order Now! Call 812-849-2967 or Order Online

*Online ordering only available for Mitchell location.

Welcome to Chicago’s Pizza!

We aim to provide great service and even better food in a family friendly environment.

By using only the finest ingredients in all of our products, we’re able to provide a premium dining experience. We use
our own recipes for dough, pizza sauce, and spaghetti sauce. Our produce is delivered fresh daily. And we top all of our
pizzas with industry-leading Grande Cheese.

So please, look through our menu, find something tasty, and find out what separates Chicago’s Pizza from everyone else

3221 South State Road 37
Mitchell, IN 47446

Sign up for the Mitchell newsletter!

Sign up to receive updates and special offers!


    Monday – Thursday – 11:00am – 9:00pm
    Friday – Saturday – 11:00am – 10:00pm
    Sunday – 11:30am – 9:00pm

    Currently all Chicago’s Pizza locations are open at partial capacity. We are implementing increased sanitization and staff screening. All employees are wearing face masks and wash and sanitize their hands frequently. Our hours of operation may be reduced; call ahead to confirm hours. We will continue to monitor and implement the local and state-wide requirements. Thank you for your understanding, patience and continued support.


    Facebook: @chicagospizzamitchell
    Instagram: @chicagospizzamitchell


    Please send your questions, comments and suggestions regarding our Chicago's Pizza restaurant in Mitchell to us at We will respond within 48 hours.



    Soft Drinks

    free refills on dine-in

    Pepsi, Caffeine Free Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Lemonade,
    Sweet Tea, and Iced Tea

    Bottled Beer

    Budweiser, Bud Light, AmberBock, Upland Wheat

    Limit 3 Per Person.
    We card everyone, so please be prepared


    A few of our favorites! Great as a pre-meal snack or as entrees in their own right.

    Our traditional dough, made from scratch with an original recipe, hand-rolled and baked to perfection.

    Full Order (six sticks) or Half Order (three sticks)

    Pepperoni Sticks
    Our original-recipe traditional dough, stretched, filled with pepperoni and mozzarella, rolled, and baked to order.

    Three sticks, two regular sauces

    Garlic Cheese Bread
    Italian bread, shaved, generously brushed with garlic butter, and baked with mozzarella cheese.

    Full Order (12" loaf) or Half Order (6" loaf)

    Six tender, flavorful meatballs, served with a cup of our homemade tomato sauce.

    Regular Sauces
    Nacho Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Garlic Butter, Tomato Sauce

    Premium Sauces
    Alfredo, Meat Sauce

    Wings & Bites

    Boneless Bites
    Bites of all-white meat chicken, drizzled with your favorite sauce.
    Served by weight in small and large orders.
    Includes ranch or blue cheese

    Bone-In Wings
    Traditional bone-in wings, drizzled with your favorite sauce. Served in orders of six, twelve, or twenty-four.
    Includes one ranch or blue cheese

    Wing Sauces
    Buffalo, BBQ Sauce, Sweet Chili, Garlic Parmesan


    Tossed Salad
    A romaine lettuce blend with cucumbers, tomatoes, cheese, and croutons. Includes one cup of dressing.

    Chicken Salad
    Pieces of grilled, all-white-meat chicken top a romaine lettuce blend with cucumbers, tomatoes, cheese, and croutons.
    Includes two cups of dressing.

    Chef Salad
    We start with our romaine blend lettuce, top it with tomatoes, cucumbers, broccoli, eggs, onions, cheese, and chopped
    ham. Includes two cups of dressing.

    Salad Bar

    One-Trip Salad Bar
    Enjoy a single trip to our salad bar, which includes an array of fresh produce and tasty veggies (all delivered daily).

    Junior Salad Bar
    A smaller portioned plate, perfect for children or those looking for a light salad.
    Only available with the purchase of a pizza or entree.

    The salad-bar price reflects the necessary cost of providing fresh, quality items delivered on a daily basis.

    Ranch, Fat-Free Catalina, Golden Italian, 1000 Island, Blue Cheese, and Raspberry Vinaigrette


    All sandwiches are baked on Italian bread with mozzarella cheese and served with chips.

    Available in Full (12") or Half (6") sizes

    Hot Ham & Cheese
    Thinly sliced honey-cured ham (which we slice daily in-house) drizzled with our creamy Italian dressing.

    Crumbled pork sausage, topped with slivered onions and our homemade pizza sauce.

    Grilled Chicken
    Grilled, all-white meat chicken, chopped and sauced with your choice of honey mustard or sweet BBQ.

    Slices of our meatballs, topped with onions, green peppers, and our homemade meat sauce.

    Our spin on a classic. Pepperoni, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with mayo on the side.


    Extra-thin spaghettini noodles, imported from Italy, topped with our homemade plain or meat sauce.

    Available as a Full or Half order

    Alfredo Penne
    Heartier penne noodles, imported from Italy, topped with alfredo, and baked with parmesan.


    Chicken Alfredo Penne
    Heartier penne noodles, imported from Italy, topped with alfredo and chicken, and baked with parmesan.

    Cheesy Baked Ziti
    Penne Noodles, with your choice of our homemade plain or meat sauce, and baked with mozzarella cheese.

    Lasagna noodles with sausage, ground beef, parmesan, Italian seasoning, and our homemade marinara. Topped with


    Pasta dishes receive three breadsticks.
    Upgrade breadsticks to garlic cheese bread for an additional cost.

    Regular and Premium Dipping Sauces available.

    When considering pasta, please be mindful that our homemade marinara is a sweet sauce.

    Specialty Pizzas

    Available with Traditional crust in the following sizes:

    • Personal
    • Small
    • Medium
    • Large
    • Jumbo

    Crispy Thin Crust available (small & large only)
    Deep Dish Crust available (small & large only)


    Garlic Cheese Pizza
    We start with lots of garlic butter, add plenty of mozzarella, and soft bake it for doughier texture.
    Traditional only

    Honey-cured ham, sliced thin, chopped, and topped with pineapple.


    Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom, Green Pepper, and Onion.


    traditionalAll Meat
    Pepperoni, Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Bacon, and Ground Beef.


    Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive, and Tomato


    Pepperoni Classic
    For our Pepperoni lovers. An extra loaded portion of Pepperoni topped with extra cheese.


    Chicken Pizza
    Chunks of grilled, all-white meat chicken and your choice of BBQ, Alfredo, Ranch, or Buffalo.


    Magnificent Mile
    Pepperoni, Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Bacon, Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, and Black Olive.

    Create your own pizza


    Our hand-tossed crust. We make it from scratch each day with our original dough recipe.

    Available in the following sizes:

    • Personal (7")
    • Small (10")
    • Medium (12")
    • Large (14")
    • Jumbo (18")

    Deep Dish
    Our thickest crust. Made from scratch from our other dough recipe and baked in a pan. Please allow a few extra moments
    baking time for deep dish.
    Available as 10" and 14" only

    Crispy Thin
    Our thinnest crust. This crispy crust is light on bread and big on flavor. Perfect for those with lighter appetites.

    Almost Gluten-Free
    Because we make our own dough in our kitchen area and utilize ingredients with gluten, we can never offer a truly
    gluten-free pizza. We can offer gluten-free crust that makes a great low-gluten pizza.
    Available as 10” Only

    Ultimate Cheese
    A premium extra portion of cheese (coupons not applicable to Ultimate Cheese)


    Pepperoni, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Ham, Ground Beef, Canadian Bacon, Bacon

    Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Black Olive, Green Olive, Banana Pepper, Pineapple, Tomato, Jalapeno

    Sauce Upgrades
    Spice up your pizza with one of these great sauces!
    Priced as one topping

    Ranch, BBQ Sauce, Alfredo, Buffalo


    Dessert Pizza
    ART_1309Our homemade dough, baked soft, buttered, covered in cinnamon/sugar, and
    glazed with vanilla icing.
    Available in Small (9") and Large(13") sizes

    9" Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

    Chicago’s also offers...

    Discounts on large carry-out orders

    Inquire for details

    A birthday club

    Text CPMBDAY to 57711

    Church, school, team, & club discounts

    Inquire for details

    Gift Cards

    Gift Certificates available in store


    Perfect for schools, teams, churches, groups, bands and clubs!

    Options include:

    •  Pizza and Breadsticks Cards
    •  Take and Bake Pizzas
    •  Takeover Nights

    A Chicago’s Pizza Fundraiser is a simple and effective way for your group to raise significant money. Our representative
    will guide you through the sales process. Chicago’s
    will deliver your group order at the prearranged time and place. The product will be a professionally packaged ready to
    bake pizza with preparation instructions enclosed. Past experience has shown that a Chicago’s Pizza Fundraiser is
    popular, hassle-free
    and it works.

    Mitchell Fundraiser Flyer
    Mitchell Fundraiser Sales Form

    Call 812-849-2967 for