Chicago's Pizza // Spencer                                   

Order Now!  812-829-7222

168 E Morgan St

Spencer, IN 47460


Monday – Tuesday - 10:30am – 8:30pm
Wednesday – Friday - 10:30am – 9:00pm
Saturday – Sunday - 11:30am – 9:00pm

Currently all Chicago’s Pizza locations are open at partial capacity. We are implementing increased sanitization and staff screening. All employees are wearing face masks and wash and sanitize their hands frequently. Our hours of operation may be reduced; call ahead to confirm hours. We will continue to monitor and implement the local and state-wide requirements. Thank you for your understanding, patience and continued support.


Facebook: @chicagospizzaspencer
Instagram: @chicagospizza.indy




Freshly rolled dough - made in-house daily - baked to perfection and lightly buttered.
Full Order
Six breadsticks and two dipping sauces

Half Order
Three breadsticks and one dipping sauce


Pepperoni Sticks
Our freshly made dough filled with pepperoni and mozzarella.
Order of Three 
Three sticks and one dipping sauce

Garlic Cheese Loaf
Italian bread, brushed in garlic butter, and topped with melted mozzarella.
One Order 
Twelve-inch loaf, cut into four pieces

Garlic Bread
Italian, brushed in garlic butter, and baked until golden brown.
One Order 
Twelve-inch loaf, cut into four pieces

Tomato Bread
Our garlic cheese loaf with tomato sauce and sliced tomatoes added.
One Order 
Twelve-inch loaf, cut into four pieces

Regular Dipping Sauces
Tomato Sauce, Nacho Cheese, Mild Cheese, Garlic Butter


(free refills on dine-in drinks)

We proudly serve Pepsi products, iced tea, and lemonade.

Garden Greens


House Garden Salad
A side salad with fresh greens, tomato, and cucumber with crackers upon request.

Chef Salad
Plenty of crisp lettuce with garden vegetables. Topped with ham, boiled eggs, and cheese with crackers
upon request.

Farmer's Grilled Chicken Salad
Fresh lettuce, topped with tomatoes, cheese, and eggs. Finished with strips of grilled chicken and your
favorite dressing. Crackers upon request.

Dressing Choices
Ranch, Bleu Cheese, French, Creamy Italian, Fat-Free French, Fat-Free Ranch, Fat-Free Zesty

Salad Bar

Indulge in our endless salad bar, complete with today's soup and fresh-baked breadsticks.


Enjoy our delicious pizza with our all-you-can-eat buffet. Includes a beverage.

Seven Days a Week
11:00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m.

Soup Bowl

Today's Soup
Made hot and fresh every day.

Soup and Salad
Enjoy a bowl of today's soup with a crisp garden salad.

Soup and Sticks
A winning combination of our daily soup and three breadsticks. Served with one dipping sauce.


All sandwiches come on toasted French bread with melted mozzarella and are served with chips.
Pickles and peppers available upon request.

Super (12")
Regular (6")

Crumbled sausage, onions, and our pizza sauce.

Grilled Chicken
Chopped chicken, with your choice of BBQ sauce, honey dijon, or buffalo.

Ham and Cheese
Honey-cured ham sliced thin and topped with our Creamy Italian dressing.

Turkey Club
Slices of turkey, bits of bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with mayonnaise.

Baked Potatoes

Basic Baker
A baked potato with butter and sour cream.

Bacon and Cheese
A baked potato with butter, bacon, and cheddar.

Ham and Cheese
A baked potato with butter, ham, and cheddar.

Broccoli and Cheese
A baked potato with butter, broccoli, and cheddar.

The Works
A baked potato stuffed with butter, ham, bacon, broccoli, cheddar, and sour cream.

Create Your Own Pizza

Traditional Crust
Our famous, hand-rolled dough. Stretched and hand-tossed.

Crispy Thin - Available in 14" Large

Deep-Dish Crust
Sicilian style, baked in a pan, using our homemade dough recipe.

Meat Toppings
Pepperoni, Ground Beef, Bacon, Italian Sausage, Sausage, Ham, Anchovies, Chicken.

Non-Meat Toppings
Onions, Mushrooms, Pineapples, Black Olives, Jalapeno Peppers, Green Peppers, Spinach, Tomatoes, Banana