Tell City

Chicago's Pizza // Tell City

Order Now! 812-547-4060

1023 Payne St.
Tell City, IN 47586


Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 am–9:00 pm 
Friday – Saturday: 11:00 am–10:00 pm 

Currently all Chicago’s Pizza locations are open at partial capacity. We are implementing increased sanitization and staff screening. All employees are wearing face masks and wash and sanitize their hands frequently. Our hours of operation may be reduced; call ahead to confirm hours. We will continue to monitor and implement the local and state-wide requirements. Thank you for your understanding, patience and continued support.


Facebook: Chicago's Pizza of Tell City
Instagram: @chicagospizza.indy



Soft Drinks

free refills on dine-in

Pepsi, Caffeine Free Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist,
Dr. Pepper, Root Beer, Lemonade, Iced Tea, Sweet Tea

Bottled Beer
10 oz and 16 oz draft

Chicago's Proudly Offers:
St. Benedict's Brew Works
Ferdinand, IN
Ask server for selections and prices


Rolled fresh daily with our hand-made dough.
Baked to a golden brown and lightly buttered.

Full Order (six sticks, 2 regular sauces)
Half Order (three sticks, 1 regular sauce)

Pepperoni Sticks
Our famous traditional dough filled with mozzarella and pepperoni

Order of three sticks, 2 regular sauces

Garlic Cheese Bread
Italian bread, shaved, brushed with garlic butter, and topped with mozzarella.

12" loaf

Regular Sauces
Tomato Sauce, Nacho Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, Garlic Butter

Wild Wings
Chicken wings doused with our spicy sauce (order of six wings)


Tossed Salad
A dinner salad with crisp lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, croutons, and cheese.

Grilled Chicken Salad
Our romaine blend lettuce, with cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and cheese. Finished with grilled chicken.

Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey-Mustard, 1000 Island, Italian, Fat-Free Catalina

One-Trip Salad Bar
Enjoy our array of veggies, all delivered fresh daily. Take a look, it's no ordinary salad bar.


All sandwiches are prepared on Italian bread, baked with mozzarella cheese, and served with chips.

Full (12")
Half (6")

Crumbled sausage, onions, and our homemade pizza sauce. An old favorite.

Grilled Chicken
Grilled chicken topped with your choice of BBQ, honey mustard, buffalo, or ranch.

Our premium meatballs, sliced and topped with onions, green peppers, and our meat sauce.

BBQ Roast Beef
Our spicy barbecue sauce gives this savory roast beef sandwich its great flavor, smothered in melted mozzarella.

Turkey Bacon Club
Sliced turkey with bacon, lettuce, tomato. Served with mayo on the side.

Hot Ham & Cheese
Thinly sliced, honey-cured ham drizzled with our creamy Italian dressing.

Italian Beef
Tender roast beef stacked marinated in seasoned au jus and served on an Italian roll.


Pasta dishes receive three breadsticks.
Dipping sauces available
Upgrade sticks to garlic cheese bread

Extra-thin spaghetti noodles, imported from Italy.

Available as a Full or Half order

Sauces available: Plain, Meat, Alfredo


Heartier penne noodles.

w/ Plain or Meat Sauce
w/ Alfredo
w/ Alfredo and Chicken
Alfredo penne dishes baked w/ parmesan.


Pasta Extras

Add Mushrooms
Three Meatballs w/ Pasta
Three Meatballs a la carte
Add Chicken


Baked Ziti
Penne noodles baked with mozzarella cheese with plain or meat sauce


Lasagna noodles with ground beef, sausage, mozzarella, Italian seasoning, and our homemade sauce.


With the exception of our alfredo offerings, we prepare each of our pasta dishes with
homemade spaghetti sauce, which is a bit sweet. For those that don't care for sweeter sauces,
we do suggest looking at other areas of the menu.

Specialty Pizzas

The 29" Party Pizza
Bring your family and friends to share this giant 29 inch pizza.
It's topped with any of your favorites and can feed 15-20 people.


The perfect blend of chopped ham and juicy pineapple.


Plenty of pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, and green pepper. Our signature pie.


All Meat
Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, bacon, and ground beef.


Vegetable Love
Mushrooms, onion, green pepper, black olive, and tomato.


Magnificent Mile
This one's loaded. Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, bacon, mushroom, onion, green pepper, and black olive.


Grilled Chicken
Grilled, all-white meat chicken and onions. Your choice of pizza sauce, BBQ, Ranch, Alfredo, Buffalo, or Buffalo Ranch.


Gluten-Free Crust
A 10" gluten-free crust. We use separate utensils, but prepare it alongside our other pizzas and can't guarantee the resulting pizza as gluten-free.


Dessert Pizza
Fluffy, soft-baked dough, buttered, covered with cinnamon/sugar, and topped w/icing.

Small (9")
Large (13")

Craft Your Own Pizza

1. Choose a Crust...

Hand-tossed from freshly made dough.

Deep Dish
Pan pizza from our other famous recipe.

Crispy Thin
A light, flavorful crust with a crispy texture.

2. Your Pizza Size...

Small 10"
Serves 1-2, available in all crusts

Medium 12"
Serves 2-3, traditional only

Large 14"
Serves 3-4, available in all crusts

Jumbo 18"
Serves 4-6, traditional only

3. And your toppings...

Meat Toppings
Pepperoni, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Ham, Ground Beef, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Anchovies

Non Meat Toppings
Banana Peppers, Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Pineapple, Jalapeno Peppers, Green Olives



Our fresh made dough, prepared daily in-house, stretched and hand tossed.  Hearty but thinner than our deep dish pizza

Available with traditional crust in the following sizes:

  • Small (10")
  • Medium (12")
  • Large (14")
  • Jumbo (18")


Crispy Thin

Available with crispy thin crust in the following sizes:

  • Small (10")
  • Large (14")


Deep Dish

Our special recipe dough, pressed in olive oil and baked in a pan.  A thicker crust with more ample toppings and cheese

Available with deep dish crust in the following sizes:

  • Small (10")
  • Large (14")


Perfect for schools, teams, churches, groups, bands and clubs!

Options include:

•  Pizza and Breadsticks Cards
•  Take and Bake Pizzas

A Chicago’s Pizza Fundraiser is a simple and effective way for your group to raise significant money. Our representative will guide you through the sales process. Chicago’s will deliver your group order at the prearranged time and place. The product will be a professionally packaged ready to bake pizza with preparation instructions enclosed. Past experience has shown that a Chicago’s Pizza Fundraiser is popular, hassle-free and it works.

Tell City Fundraiser Flyer
Tell City Fundraiser Sales Form